The Best Italian Restaurants in Sarasota

We have compiled a list of our favorite neighborhoods in Sarasota, Florida, and great things to do during the weekend. Check them out here!

If you are looking to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine, then you should try one of the many Italian restaurants in Sarasota. These restaurants have great Italian dishes, and you can expect to find many seafood options, too. You will find that everything is prepared fresh and in-house. For example, you can try mussels in a variety of different ways.

Eleni’s Pizza Works

This laid-back eatery serves traditional Italian favorites like pizza and panini, as well as Greek sandwiches. It has a cozy patio and booth seating. The restaurant also offers catering. The staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable. It also has plenty of parking.

One of Sarasota’s most popular restaurants, Eleni’s Pizza Works has been around for over a decade. It offers several different varieties of pizza, several types of Stromboli, and a variety of pasta. It also offers wings and is located at 6711 15th St. E.

You can order from the menu and pick up or get delivery. The restaurant also offers lunch specials. You can even enjoy a drink in the bar. It is open seven days a week, and they have a happy hour on Thursdays. The staff is attentive, and you’ll feel at home in a comfortable atmosphere.

Another great Italian restaurant in Sarasota is Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar. The family that owns this establishment moved to Sarasota from Parco del Veio, Italy. The restaurant features traditional Italian dishes and uses fresh ingredients to create delicious dishes. There’s a full bar and a good wine selection.

Mediterraneo

A White-tablecloth Italian restaurant run by Italian owners, Mediterraneo Sarasota specializes in Italian food. Its friendly service and warm atmosphere will make you feel as if you’re at home in Italy. The cuisine is authentic and flavorful, and the owners make every dish from scratch.

Located in the heart of downtown Sarasota, Mediterraneo serves Northern Italian fare. The menu features seafood, specialty pasta dishes and wood-fired pizza. There are three semi-private dining rooms, and you can choose from an excellent wine list.

Another authentic Italian restaurant in Sarasota is La Mucca Ballerina. The family who owns the restaurant hails from the Parco del Veio region, outside of Rome. This quaint restaurant offers traditional Italian dishes, made with fresh ingredients. For dessert, try a cannoli or tiramisu.

La Dolce Vita, which opened in 1989, is another option. Owned by Mauro and Tina, this family-run restaurant has a casual ambiance and Italian-inspired dishes. Some of the dishes on the menu are chicken marsala and veal parmigiana. The restaurant also offers pizzas, tortelloni and Chiara’s Tiramisu.

Cafe Gabbiano

This rustic-elegant eatery features patio seating, a long wine list, and upscale Italian classics. Located just off the waterfront, the restaurant is a perfect choice for a date night or a relaxing dinner with friends. The menu is extensive and features dishes like veal piccata, mussels, and spaghetti bolognese.

The menu is made to order, featuring a variety of authentic Italian dishes prepared by a head chef from an island off Naples. The moderately priced dinner menu features fresh pastas, hand-cut veal, free-range chicken, and freshly-made mozzarella. The menu also includes local seafood, if available. The restaurant also offers a four-course tasting menu and discounts on wine to-go.

Cafe Gabbiano is an Italian restaurant on Siesta Key. Originally owned by Chef Pietro Migliaccio, it was recently taken over by Peter Tracy and Marc Grimaud. The menu offers traditional dishes like carne, pollo, and pesce, and has a large wine list. The menu also offers antipasti dishes.

The Sardinia Restaurant in midtown Sarasota is another excellent choice. It has been praised by the Wall Street Journal for its outstanding cuisine. Sardinia’s menu has creative and satisfying Italian dishes that are sure to please any palate. The restaurant’s Savor Sarasota menu features octopus carpaccio with housemate bottarga, ricotta and orange zest ravioli, and roasted Mediterranean sea bass with anchovies.

Bavaro’s

Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria Sarasota is a family-run Italian restaurant that’s a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. This pizzeria is Florida’s first authentic Neapolitan pizzaria and has been a favorite among locals since it opened in 2009. The ingredients used in Bavaro’s pizzas are imported directly from Italy.

Bavaro’s serves Italian comfort food, and their homemade mozzarella is legendary. It’s hard to go wrong with this pizza, which is baked fresh daily. It’s a great place to enjoy an informal lunch or dinner. Among the many Italian dishes served at this restaurant are Cacio e Pepe, which is a dish that’s sure to satisfy. The pasta sauce is rich and delicious, and the pepperoni is juicy and flavorful.

Another popular choice is Bavaro’s Pizza, a Tampa Bay chain that’s been serving authentic pizzas and pasta for more than a century. In addition to pizzas, Bavaro’s also offers an extensive menu of Italian comfort foods, including spaghetti and meatballs and tagliatelle Bolognese. The restaurant also offers a charcuterie board and live music.

The restaurant’s crispy crust is legendary for its pizzas, and you can even request a light-cooked pizza if you don’t like crunchy crusts. Another favorite pizza is the Pollo Pazzo, a combination of blackened chicken, sweet onion, and 3 cheeses. Another great option is the margherita pizza, which comes with authentic house-made mozzarella. For those with dietary restrictions, a gluten-free version is available with a crunchy cauliflower crust.

Cassariano

The name Cassariano is derived from the last names of the partners. Luca and Antonio had worked together in the restaurant industry for many years before deciding to open their own eatery. Their goal was to combine authentic Italian cuisine with a relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant’s atmosphere is a mixture of a traditional Italian bistro and a modern, hip ambiance.

The restaurant has two locations: indoor and outdoor. Both locations feature outdoor seating. Cassariano is family-owned and operated, and it is a popular destination in the Sarasota area. Customers can also order takeout or delivery. The staff is courteous, welcoming, and happy to serve you.

Ristorante offers romantic ambiance, while Italian-themed dining options include wood-burned pizzas and gourmet entrees. Cassariano also offers an extensive wine list. The restaurant’s menu features dishes from many of Italy’s provinces.